The Appraisal Came In Low. Does That Mean the Buyer Gets the House for Less?

The Appraisal Came In Low. Does That Mean the Buyer Gets the House for Less?

This is one of the biggest misconceptions I hear once a transaction is already in escrow.

The appraisal comes back below the contract price and suddenly everybody thinks:

“Well, I guess that's the new price.”

Not exactly.

A low appraisal can create a negotiation.

It does not automatically rewrite the purchase contract.

First, What Is the Appraisal Actually Doing?

If the buyer is financing the purchase, the lender generally orders an appraisal to help determine the property's value for lending purposes.

Let's say we're under contract at $750,000.

The appraisal comes in at $735,000.

That $15,000 difference is what people commonly call an appraisal gap.

Now we need to look at the contract.

Does the buyer have an appraisal contingency?

Has it already been removed?

Was an appraisal-gap provision negotiated when we wrote the offer?

Those details matter.

Sellers Don't Automatically Have to Reduce the Price

This is the part sellers need to hear.

A low appraisal does not automatically mean:

“You have to sell for the appraised value.”

Depending on the contract, we may have several possible paths.

The seller could agree to reduce the price.

The buyer could potentially bring additional cash.

The parties could negotiate somewhere in the middle.

The buyer may have contractual rights depending on the appraisal contingency.

Or we may have grounds to question the appraisal itself.

Buyers: Don't Panic Either

A low appraisal doesn't automatically mean you're overpaying.

Appraisals are opinions of value based on the appraiser's analysis of the property and comparable sales.

Sometimes there may be relevant information worth reviewing.

Did the appraiser have the correct square footage?

Were important upgrades considered?

Were there more appropriate comparable sales?

Did something factual get missed?

If there's a legitimate issue, the lender may have a process for a reconsideration of value.

That doesn't mean we argue with an appraisal simply because we don't like the number.

It means we review the information before deciding what happens next.

The Market Matters Too

We're currently in a market where buyers have more negotiating leverage nationally. Redfin recently reported that new listings reached a four-month high while pending sales fell to a six-month low, giving serious buyers more opportunities to negotiate price and concessions.

That matters.

If I'm representing a seller and we have five backup buyers waiting, my strategy may look very different than if we've been listed for 70 days and this is our only buyer.

If I'm representing the buyer, I'm looking at that same leverage from the opposite side.

Real estate negotiation doesn't happen in a vacuum.

My Advice

If the appraisal comes in low, don't immediately jump to:

“The deal is dead.”

And don't assume:

“The seller has to lower the price.”

First, let's answer:

What does the contract say?

How large is the gap?

What financing is involved?

What does the appraisal actually show?

What leverage does each side have?

Then we negotiate.

Because the appraisal is important.

But what happens after a low appraisal is determined by the contract, the financing, the market and the negotiation—not by one number alone.

Register for the FREE SoCal Home Buying Class

Mercedes Erhahon – RESWealthy Team
Real Brokerage, Powered by PLACE
909-413-0602
www.RESWealthyTeam.com